Recently the City of Elliot Lake decided to reduce the number of hours that the local airport would remain open. With the lack of air traffic and high costs of manning the airport it made sense fiscally, but has dealt a blow to local citizens and forecasters like myself. The collateral damage, from this decision, now means no weather reports from the airport during these closures.
Now if you live in Elliot Lake you find out that your local conditions for evenings, weekends and holidays are now coming from Gore Bay Airport – over 55km away. That would be like someone in Toronto getting local weather information from Niagara Falls. Certainly this would be unacceptable to the millions in Southern Ontario but Northerners are expected to settle for less.
For forecasters like myself it becomes very difficult to verify forecasts and adjust forecast model outputs for variances based on realtime information. We all know (and the reason I started this site!) is that weather forecasts, from mainstream sources like Environment Canada and The Weather Network are poor to terrible. For anyone that makes a living based on accurate weather forecasts it becomes a crap-shoot to find the needed information. This elimination of weather data from Elliot Lake only weakens the already sparse network.
The area from Sault Ste. Marie to Sudbury and from the North Shore to Chapleau is over 55,000 square kilometers! 10 times the size of Prince Edward Island and roughly the same size as Nova Scotia. This area now contains ZERO weather reporting stations during the night, holidays and weekends – I guess weather doesn’t exist outside office hours, in these regions. Meanwhile in Prince Edward Island there a SIX weather stations (remember a tenth of the size) and in Nova Scotia there are 26 reporting stations!! 26!!!… and we have ZERO!!
In Nova Scotia they have 23 forecast regions while we have 15. So each forecast region is fine-tuned to about 2,300 sq’km for our Atlantic cousins while our forecast regions are ballooned to 6,600 sq.km!! That would equivalent to the area in Southern Ontario from London to the Michigan border but guess have many forecast regions they have there? SIX! They have 6 detailed forecast regions in Southwestern Ontario to 1 of ours. Therefore the forecasts could be 6 times more accurate since the resolution is so fine. That would explain why Northern Forecasts are SO terrible.
Population demographics suggest that more effort should be put into forecasts for the bulk of the population – but hold on….. This would have to mean that living in Northern Ontario condemns citizens to less government service than those in the south. It seems hardly fair and is downright insulting!
In the last decade Newfoundland fought to get it’s weather forecast office back; after it was outsourced to Nova Scotia. The size of our little chunk of Northern Ontario is the SAME size as Newfoundland – but we don’t have a dedicated forecast office (it’s in Toronto!)
I would think the challenges faced by Toronto region citizens are no greater than those in the north. We also need accurate forecasts to plan safe travels along the highways, we need accurate information for agricultural activities, we need detailed warnings for severe weather. So we should get the SAME service from our government forecasting service.
The sad truth is that the manually weather observations in Elliot Lake will likely not return unless the mines reopen and the airport becomes busier. It is more likely that Environment Canada places an automated station at the airport than the return of staff. This automation only feeds into continued automation of our government weather offices. They days of real forecasters, who know the region they forecast for, has come and gone. It’s already automated – and performing poorly for us folks in the north and it won’t get better with less information to feed into those super-computers.
I try to do my bit, part-time from my basement forecast office, to help provide more accurate forecasts for the north but the elimination of weather reports, from places like Elliot Lake, only make the job tougher. I would rather Environment Canada give the resources to someone like myself that has a genuine interest in accurate, meaningful weather information. If this WAS my full-time gig, Northerns wouldn’t have to settle anymore!






Yesterday I took a trip north and drove out of the desert and into a more mountainous location, enroute to the Grand Canyon.

